Demystifying The Music Industry: What’s The Difference Between ASCAP/BMI/SESAC and SoundExchange?

I received an email this morning from a reader who had read my piece, “Demystifying The Music Industry: What’s This About Public Performance Rights?.” He asked, “If SoundExchange was designated by the Library of Congress as the sole PRO to administer public performance licenses and also collect public performances fees for Sound Recording Company Owners, then why do artists still utilize the services provided by the other 3 US PROs (ASCAP / BMI / SESAC) – is [SoundExchange] not sufficient by itself?”

A lot of indie artists are confused about the difference between ASCAP, BMI, SESAC and SoundExchange. I’ll attempt to break down the most important differences between these groups and elaborate towards the end about other considerations and other royalty collection entities. Feel free to comment with any questions (or corrections). 

ASCAP (American Society of Composers, Authors, and Publishers), BMI (Broadcast Music, Inc.) and SESAC are US public performance organizations (PROs) who collect royalties for the PUBLIC PERFORMANCE of musical works as stipulated by the U.S. Copyright Act. This includes fees paid by radio stations, businesses, restaurants, concert venues, bars, nightclubs, sports arenas, bowling alleys, malls and shopping centers, amusement parks, colleges & universities, etc. for performing music in the public (within the confines of their establishment). These monies are paid to ASCAP, BMI and SESAC for a blanket public performance license that grants the licensee (the business) permission to allow music to be performed in their environment (this includes music over speakers and music performed live by an artist). The license fees paid to ASCAP, BMI and SESAC are passed on to the copyright owners in the musical works (song) — PUBLISHERS (50%) and SONGWRITERS (50%) — as performance royalties for musical works.

SoundExchange is a US public performance organization (PRO) who collects royalties for DIGITAL PUBLIC PERFORMANCE of sound recordings stipulated by the Digital Performance Right in Sound Recording Act of 1995 and Digital Millennium Copyright Act of 1998. This includes fees paid by music service providers (MSPs) to stream music over satellite (SiriusXM), internet (Pandora, Spotify, iTunes Radio, Rdio, Rhapsody), cable (Music Choice, Verve) and other digital means as stipulated by law. These fees are paid to SoundExchange for a digital statutory license, under sections 112 and 114 of the Copyright Act, to stream sound recordings. The license fees paid to SoundExchange are passed on to copyright owners in the sound recording (master) — RECORD LABEL (50%), FEATURED ARTIST (45%), and NON-FEATURED ARTISTS (i.e. background vocalist, session musicians, etc.) (5%) — as digital statutory royalties for sound recordings.

Things to know…

  • With some exceptions (mostly political) ARTISTS do not receive performance royalties in musical works (ASCAP/BMI/SESAC) unless they wrote the song. So, Rihanna does not earn performance royalties in musical works when she performs “Stay” or when you listen to it on the radio or in a coffee house.
  • With some exceptions (mostly political) SONGWRITERS do not receive digital statutory royalties in sound recordings (SoundExchange) unless they also recorded the song with their vocals. So, Diane Warren does not earn digital statutory royalties in sound recordings when you hear any of the songs she wrote for Whitney Houston, Enrique Iglesias, Faith Hill (and the list goes on) on Pandora or iTunes Radio. [Update: However, Diane Warren does earn public performance royalties in the musical works (ASCAP/BMI/SESAC) for these transmissions (Thanks Professor Surmani of the Masters of Artists in Music Industry Administration program at CSUN for catching this misleading omission!).]
  • Pandora, Rdio, iTunes Radio, Spotitfy, etc. must pay both ASCAP, BMI, SESAC public performance fees for musical works and SoundExchange digital performance fees for sound recordings. Clear Channel radio stations, such as KISS FM, only has to pay ASCAP, BMI, SESAC public performance fees for musical works, but not SoundExchange digital performance fees for sound recordings because of special stipulations in the US Copyright Act for broadcast radio. This is part of the reason why Pandora wants to reduce the royalties it pays.
  • Royalties collected by SoundExchange can expire if the artist does not register to collect them!!!

There are lots of other sound recording royalties (besides the digital royalties collected by SoundExchange) that are collected on behalf of featured recording artists, non-featured artists (ie. background or session vocalists), instrumental musicians, etc. They include:

  • sound recording revenue (also known as DART royalties, which stands for Digital Audio Recorders and Tapes) generated from the U.S. Audio Home Recording Act of 1992 (AHRA). Manufactures and importers of audio home recording devices (such as tape recorders) and audio home recording media (such as black CDs) pay a royalty to the Copyright Office;
  • sound recording revenue generated from reciprocal Private Copy agreements with numerous foreign collectives in countries that also have legislation providing these royalties such as: Japan, the Netherlands, Hungary, Spain, Portugal, Greece, Germany, Latvia, and Estonia, just to name a few;
  • sound recording revenue from record rentals remuneration from Japan, where sound recordings are rented in much the same manner DVDs are rented here in the U.S.;
  • sound recording revenue generated digital public performance from the Digital Performance Right in Sound Recordings Act of 1995 (DPRA) and the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) paid to SoundExchange (as discussed above);
  • sound recording revenue generated from a treaty with AIE, Sociedad de Gestión – the Spanish Rights Collective. The Audiovisual Division of the AFM & SAG-AFTRA Intellectual Property Rights Distribution Fund (established in 2010) distributes payments collected from any television show or motion picture that is broadcast on Spanish television and contains the performance of an AFM or SAG-AFTRA vocalist;
  • sound recording revenue collected by the Symphonic Royalties division of the AFM & SAG-AFTRA Intellectual Property Rights Distribution Fund, which are royalties for performers on Symphonic sound recordings, including musicians and singers of an orchestra.
  • sound recording revenue from master use licenses between record companies and film/TV production companies (TV shows, movies, and web series), advertisers (commercials and products), video games; and
  • sound recording revenue from compulsory mechanical licenses for sample use in other songs, copies and re-distribution, and ringtones.

There are lots of other musical works royalties (besides the public performance royalties collected by ASCAP/BMI/SESAC) that are collected on behalf of songwriters, music producers and publishers:

  • publishing revenue from synchronization rights of music to film/TV, video games, or commercial. (Collected by publisher);
  • publishing revenue from lyric print rights used in music apps, books and magazines, apparel, websites (like the lyric websites), or sheet music (such as MusicNotes.com. (Collected by publisher);
  • publishing revenue from compulsory mechanical licenses for record labels or indie artists to record and distribute music works (such as going a song placed with a major artist or an indie artist doing a cover of a song previously performed by a major artist) whether posted on YouTube or sold on a CD. (Collected by Harry Fox Agency);
  • publishing revenue from DART royalties from Audio Home Recording Act of 1992 distributed to the Music Publishers Subfund and Writers Subfund (collected by Copyright Office);
  • publishing revenue from public performance via ASCAP, BMI, or SESAC (Note: A songwriter can only be registered to one of these guys);
  • publishing revenue from foreign monies via sub-publishing agreements and other licensing arrangements in foreign territories. (Collected by PROs, publishers and other collecting entities depending on the nature of the royalties and legislation);
  • publishing revenue from hundreds of other licensing sources (collected by PROs, publishers and other collecting entities depending on the nature of the royalties and territory)

And there’s more, but I’ll leave it at that. Any questions?

Tags: , , , , ,

About Dae Bogan

Dae Bogan is a music industry professional. Connect with Dae on Twitter at @DaeBoganMusic.

15 responses to “Demystifying The Music Industry: What’s The Difference Between ASCAP/BMI/SESAC and SoundExchange?”

  1. Emmanuel Legrand says :

    Good post, very clear!
    In a nutshell, ASCAP, BMI and SESAC collect performance rights for compositions while Soundexchange does it for recordings, albeit in a more restricted legal framework.
    One slight correction regarding SoundExchange: SX collects royalties from non-interactive digital radio services. It includes cable and salellite services like Sirius/XM or Pandora, or terrestrial radio services broadcast on the net (webcasters) like iHeart Radio, but it does NOT include Spotify and other interactive services (ie. services that offer consumers the choice to pick their songs).
    And, as opposed to the European copyright legislation, it does not include public performance rights for the broadcast of music works on terrestrial radio.

    • Dae Bogan says :

      Thank you for reading Emmanuel; and I appreciate your comments.

      For clarity, Spotify does in fact pay royalties to SoundExchange for its non-interactive radio service. This is separate from its on-demand service, for which it does not pay royalties to SoundExchange. In regards to your mentioning of European copyright legislation, my piece does not speak to European copyright legislation. However, yes music played on terrestrial radio in the UK generates performance royalties collected by the PRS and PPL.

  2. Jorie says :

    My band is registered on ASCAP and SoundExchange. We’ve had tons of TripleA FM radio play (USA) and tons of Internet radio play since 2010 with 2 albums. Both albums are still being played. We are streamed on all the services, Pandora, Spotify, etc. and no royalties yet. I complained to ASCAP who told me they forgot to put the songs in the database so it’s up to us to find out how many times we were played over 4 years. WTF? No royalties from SoundExchange either.

  3. healingcolors says :

    …cheers Dae…great article…thank’s for sharing…well done…a lot to do in 2015…;-)))…my artist friends have to do some homework…

  4. healingcolors says :

    Reblogged this on …eyecare and earcare…against the blue… and commented:
    …a guide through the music jungle…big cheers to Dae Bogan…let’s rock 2015 friends…

  5. Cara Ashbey says :

    Reblogged this on CARA|ASHBEY and commented:
    Bands! Give this a read ASAP! (ASCAP is SOCAN in Canada)

  6. majai says :

    Recently we were contacted by a fashion agency with interest in licensing several of our songs. Which, I am pleased to hear; however, they are requesting that the songs not be reported to collection societies. Any thoughts on this? Part me is okay because I am not thinking there is much to collect as we have not had much FM radio support. We are kind of underground genre. Is there an in between option or solution to counter with?

    • Dae Bogan says :

      Did they explain to you why they do not want you to register your songs to collection societies?

      As a musician, you should always register your songs. It’s your right! Besides, you earn royalties from (and PROs collect from) many other sources than FM radio. Make sure to register with your PRO (ASCAP, BMI, or SESAC) as well as with SoundExchange.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: